James Toney loses UD to journeyman Charles Ellis in St. Louis
It may finally be lights out for the boxing career of James “Lights Out” Toney.
Toney, two weeks from his 47th birthday, lost a 10-round unanimous decision to journeyman Charles Ellis at the Chase Park Plaza Hotel in St. Louis on Saturday. The scores were 99-91, 98-92, 97-93.
Toney (76-10-3, 46 knockouts) had been inactive for nearly two years after losing a three-round decision to Jason Gavern in their Prizefighter heavyweight semi-final. Toney weighed 13 and a half pounds more at 231 for this match, while Ellis, 11 pounds heavier at 242, had lost consecutive bouts to Adam Kownacki and Ed Fountain heading into the fight.
Ellis (10-3-1, 8 KOs) is no spring chicken himself at 40 years of age.
The decline of Toney’s once otherworldly skill and ability has been steady, marked by a drop in punch activity and the increasing frequency of his opponents’ punches landing. He also increasingly struggled with his weight, which ranged from from 157 to 257 pounds during his career.
Toney’s career began in 1988, and three years later he won the IBF middleweight title with a come-from-behind knockout of Michael Nunn.
Toney added the super middleweight title soon after with a destruction of Iran Barkley but lost his first fight to Roy Jones Jr. in 1994. Two losses to Montell Griffin and another loss to Drake Thadzi erased Toney from the elite level of the sport as a light heavyweight.
Toney’s career had an unlikely rebirth in 2003 when he beat Vassiliy Jirov for the IBF cruiserweight title, followed by a ninth-round technical knockout of Evander Holyfield.
Toney could’ve added a heavyweight championship to his resume had he not tested positive for the banned anabolic steroid nandrolone after beating WBA heavyweight titleholder John Ruiz in 2005 (the result was later changed to a no-decision). Toney also tested positive for banned substances boldenone and stanozolol after his 2007 split-decision win over Danny Batchelder, which resulted in a one-year suspension (the decision remained as Batchelder also tested positive for banned substances.)
James Toney was the Boxing Writers Association of America Fighter of the Year in 1991 and 2003.